Home » Gerber vs American Standard Toilets: Which Brand is Better?

Gerber vs American Standard Toilets: Which Brand is Better?


When it comes time to replace or upgrade your toilet, you’ll be faced with choosing between the two most popular toilet brands: gerber vs american standard toilets. Both companies make high-quality toilets with innovative features and stylish designs.

However, there are some key differences between Gerber and American Standard toilets that you should consider before making your purchase.

Gerber Toilets Overview

Source: architectmagazine.com

Gerber has been manufacturing plumbing fixtures since 1932. They are known for producing reliable and affordable toilets in a range of styles. Here are some of the key features and benefits of Gerber toilets:

  • Durability: Gerber toilets are made from vitreous china, which is extremely durable and stain resistant. The material is fired at high temperatures to create a very strong outer glaze. This makes Gerber toilets last for years of heavy usage.
  • Water efficiency: Most Gerber toilets meet the EPA WaterSense standards, using 1.28 gallons per flush (GPF) or less. This can help households conserve water and lower utility bills.
  • Comfort height seating: Gerber offers several models in a chair height or comfort height design. The seat is roughly 2″ taller than a standard toilet, making it easier to sit down and stand up.
  • Affordable pricing: Gerber toilets are typically lower in cost than other premium brands. There are basic models under $100 and more advanced models priced under $300.
  • Variety of styles: Choose from elegant elongated bowls, compact round bowls, and modern clean-lined designs to match your bathroom’s look.

American Standard Toilets Overview

gerber vs american standard toilets
Source: superiortile.com

American Standard has been in business since 1875, manufacturing a wide range of bathroom and kitchen fixtures. They are known for very innovative toilet designs and premium quality. Here are some of the key features and benefits of American Standard toilets:

  • Powerful flushing performance: American Standard toilets feature wider trapways and optimized flush mechanisms to prevent clogs and clear waste in one flush. Many models score 1000 grams or higher in MaP testing.
  • Quiet operation: Fluance flushing systems use precision engineering to reduce water turbulence and noise when flushing. American Standard toilets are among the quietest on the market.
  • Comfort height and right height options: American Standard offers chair height and right height toilets measuring over 18″ in seating height for maximum comfort.
  • Sleek and stylish designs: American Standard toilets come in contemporary curved silhouettes and sleek rectangular shapes to complement modern bathrooms. Neutral color options are available.
  • Advanced technology: Select models feature touches like antimicrobial surfaces to inhibit odor and stain-causing bacteria. Automated flush options are also available.
  • Water efficiency: Most American Standard toilets meet stringent WaterSense standards for water conservation. Some use as little as 1 GPF.

Gerber vs American Standard Toilets: Key Comparison

Now that we’ve looked at what each brand offers, let’s directly compare Gerber and American Standard toilets across a few key factors:

FactorGerberAmerican Standard
Flushing PowerDecent but not industry-leadingExcellent, among the most powerful on the market
Water EfficiencyMeets EPA standards down to 1.28 GPFAs low as 1 GPF, exceeding EPA standards
Toilet StylesTraditional and contemporary optionsVery modern and innovative silhouette options
Comfort Height ModelsSeveral models meet chair height standardRight height and comfort height options available
Price RangeVery affordable, $100 to $300Mid-range to premium pricing, $200 to $900
Warranty CoverageLimited 1-year warrantyLengthened 10-year limited warranty

As you can see, American Standard toilets tend to edge out Gerber in terms of flushing performance, water efficiency, comfort height options, and warranty coverage. However, Gerber remains an excellent choice for shoppers on a tight budget needing a basic and affordable toilet.

Top Rated Gerber Toilet Models

Gerber offers a range of toilet models in different configurations to fit any bathroom. Here are three of their top choices:

Gerber Viper Dual Flush Toilet

This powerful dual-flush toilet uses only 1.28 GPF on the full flush setting while still providing robust cleaning action. The elongated bowl offers added room and comfort.

Gerber Avalanche Toilet

Gerber’s Avalanche model has an ultra-compact elongated bowl design making it a great option for small bathrooms. It is also very affordably priced below $200 in most stores.

Gerber Wellworth Classic Toilet

For a touch of vintage style, the Wellworth has a classic rounded silhouette combined with modern efficiency at just 1.28 GPF. It comes in white and black finish options.

Top Rated American Standard Toilet Models

American Standard also produces many high-quality toilet models with innovative features. Here are three standout options:

American Standard Champion 4 Toilet

gerber vs american standard toilets
Source: americanstandard.ca

With a massive 4-inch piston flush valve, the Champion 4 achieves incredible 1000 gram MaP scores for one-flush cleaning power. It is also very quiet in operation.

American Standard Cadet 3 FloWise Toilet

gerber vs american standard toilets
Source: lowes.com

The Cadet 3 uses just 1.28 GPF of water but still provides effective cleaning performance thanks to its engineering. The compact elongated size works in any bathroom.

American Standard VorMax Toilet

The VorMax collection combines sleek style with incredible flush power and water efficiency down to 0.8 GPF. Models come in standard or right-height configurations.

Which is Better: Gerber or American Standard?

So when it comes down to Gerber vs American Standard, which toilet brand reigns supreme?

In terms of overall performance, flushing power, innovative technology, and modern style, American Standard takes the crown as the leading toilet brand. However, Gerber remains an excellent option for shoppers needing a basic, affordable toilet that will get the job done.

American Standard offers more premium features and more powerful flush systems that excel at waste evacuation in one flush while conserving water.

Models like the VorMax and Champion 4 represent the cutting edge in toilet engineering. Though priced higher than Gerber, American Standard also often offers lengthier warranties.

However, Gerber shouldn’t be counted out. Their prices can be hundreds less than comparable American Standard toilets, bringing ownership within reach for many budgets.

Performance is also decent, meeting the baseline for water efficiency and offering durable porcelain construction. For many homeowners, a dependable Gerber toilet provides all the must-have features without breaking the bank.

So consider how much power and performance matter for your bathroom needs vs. sticking to a set budget. This can help you determine if it makes sense to invest more in an American Standard toilet or opt for an affordable and capable Gerber model instead. Either way, these two venerable plumbing brands offer quality toilets sure to serve your home well for years to come.


Q1: What is the main difference between Gerber and American Standard toilets?

A: The main difference is that American Standard toilets tend to have more powerful flush systems and more innovative features, while Gerber toilets are more affordable. American Standard is seen as the higher-end premium brand.

Q2: Do Gerber and American Standard toilets come in different heights?

A: Yes, both brands offer toilets in standard height and in taller comfort or right height configurations. American Standard has more comfort height options, while just select Gerber models meet the chair height standard.

Q3: How do the warranties compare between the brands?

A: Gerber typically offers a 1-year limited warranty on its toilets. American Standard boosts this to a lengthened 10-year limited warranty, covering more of the working toilet parts.

Q4: What kind of special features do American Standard toilets have?

A: Some innovative features found in American Standard toilets include quiet-close lids, antimicrobial surface treatments, automated flush options, and proprietary powerful flush systems like VorMax.

Q5: Which Gerber toilet models are most affordable?

A: Gerber’s Avalanche and Wellworth toilets are among their most affordably priced models, available for under $200 in many home improvement stores. This makes them budget-friendly options.

Read Next: Toto Drake II vs Ultramax II Toilet: High Efficiency Toilets Compared

Abdul Rahman

Written By:

Abdul Rahman

CEO & Lead Interior Designer

Abdul Rahman is an experienced interior designer and the founder of homedesignkey.com. With a Master's degree in Interior Design from Pratt Institute and a passion for creating safe and healthy living spaces, Brad shares his expert insights and innovative design ideas with our readers. His work is driven by the belief that home is where every story begins.

Disclaimer & Privacy Notes

Some of the images in this article, are illustrative and have been created using an AI. They are not actual photographs or accurate representations of the celebrity's home. They are intended to provide a sense of style and design that might be found in a home of this caliber. The information in this article is based on public data and does not infringe on the privacy of the celebrity.
At OmniHomeIdeas.com, we respect the privacy of all individuals, including those we feature in our articles. The details shared in this article are based on publicly available information and do not involve any invasion of personal privacy. The images are fictional and created for illustrative purposes only, aiming to inspire our readers in their own home improvement and interior design projects.

Leave a Comment